Blue Bloods
Monday, November 24th, 2008Blue Bloods by Melissa de la Cruz
Hyperion, 2006
In theory Blue Bloods has everything going for it: it’s YA, it’s got vampires and it’s got upper class Manhattan elite. I guess was expecting a sort of Twilight meets Gossip Girl bit of fun and I ‘m pretty sure that I am not alone in this, judging from the busy circulation rate of this title in my local library. Anyway, I’m sorry to say that I was disappointed.
Blue Bloods is the first book in a series of vampire meets Gossip Girl style YA books. The characters are a bunch of rich, upper east side, private school kids a la Gossip Girl. They all go to this small, fancy private school and come from elite and powerful families in some way or another. There’s a catch though–they’re vampires! In Blue Bloods the vampire teens learn about their vampire status and long vampire history (going back to the days of the pilgrims and beyond!). There’s also a strange and powerful enemy rumored to be hunting vampires, but the society seems unconcerned. Unfortunately, there’s just too many characters and the drama surrounding the story really isn’t that developed, at least in this first book.
I think what is most disappointing about Blue Bloods is that it doesn’t succeed on being catty or biting (ha!) enough to pull off the whole “Manhattan elite” thing that Gossip Girl commands. There’s a materialistic, snotty vibe that feels like it was lifted directly from the Gossip Girl style, but instead of being snarky and kind of devilishly fun, it feels flat and becomes rather irritating. Also, the vampires in Blue Bloods aren’t quite as intriguing as they should be. De la Cruz’s vampire concept is kind of interesting, but the writing doesn’t manage to make it as sexy or as dark as a vampire book should be. I was left unsure of who I would recommend Blue Bloods to. It’s too simple and formulaic to hand to any discerning Twilight fan and it’s not quite nasty enough to give to a Gossip Girl fan. I think maybe it would be suitable for younger YA readers, who are not quite ready for the thickness of Twilight or the scandal of Gossip Girl. I definitely think that there’s a place in the library for Blue Bloods (and it is checked out more often than not at my library), I just don’t think it’s the most high quality or fun to read book of its kind. It is simple enough for younger YA’s to follow though, so long as they are unconcerned with the content, which contains some sexual scenes and references and a whole lot of materialism.
